Developed Teams 2011: Cleveland Indians

Were you able to work out the identity of the other surprise Central Division contender who I mentioned in my last post? I didn't think it would be hard, but then again, I consider myself a sort of 'amateur expert' on this stuff. It should be no secret, however, that the other team I was referring to is the Cleveland Indians.

The pitching staff, which features CC Sabathia as headliner, looks a lot like the pitching staff to which CC belongs in real life - not a lot going on after the legitimate Ace. His fellow 1st round pick in the rotation, Jeremy Guthrie, now playing with Baltimore after being claimed on waivers, has some halfway decent peripherals to go with his 5-15 record, and Fausto Carmona has historically had two rotten seasons for every good one. His current rotation-mate in Cleveland, Josh Tomlin, is having a very good season, flashing some great control in just his second major league campaign.

UPDATE 8/8: When I posted this yesterday, I had listed J.D. Martin as the 5th starter, based solely on his pre-season rankings (seeing as he has spent 2011 as a swingman in AAA Syracuse), assuming that in real life, he'd compete with the two long-relief types I talk about below. However, later on, I realized a glaring omission in the statistics I had compiled for this project: namely the omission of Bartolo Colon. Maybe he slipped under my radar because he missed the entire 2010 season - but he shouldn't have because he was projected to start for the Yankees, and so far he's done a pretty nice job. The 5th starter spot is officially his, as noted in my revised graphic, above.

Jeanmar Gomez and David Huff both put up pretty good numbers for AAA Columbus, but have each made just a handful of starts for Cleveland this year.

Cleveland has developed a pretty deep bench of relievers, but they're notably lacking a proven 9th inning force. Mujica was good enough to be the centerpiece of a trade for a good young center fielder, so that gives you an idea of his talent, but he's logged only 2 Saves in his career. Pretty much the rest of the featured staff are young and effective setup men still with the Tribe (Lewis is in the minors and Laffey was traded just this off-season). And let's not forget Frank Herrmann, who has become a regular in 2011, and notable washed-up-but-once-solid veterans Danys Baez and David Riske.

The lineup's most notable features are two of the best sluggers from the '90s, Jim Thome and Manny Ramirez. Thome is currently a part-time DH, pursuing his 600th Home Run with the Twins, and Manny unceremoniously retired from the Rays after his second positive test for PED's. When healthy, Grady Sizemore has the ability to be a centerpiece for any lineup, either at the top or in the middle. Victor Martinez, while his skills behind the plate have been questioned, has leadership ability and intangibles galore. Just ask his current teammate on Detroit, Jhonny Peralta - the two All-Stars are doing their part to keep the Tigers in first place.

Peralta pushes Marco Scutaro off his normal position of SS, but he's had enough experience as a utility guy to be able to play anywhere in that infield. Before his struggles this year, I would have said that Kevin Kouzmanoff has the ability to provide great defense and middling power at the hot corner. And Russell Branyan can always be counted on to belt a few home runs, no matter the circumstances. Izturis is a great sparky presence off the bench and Ben Francisco is good enough to start in the outfield in the event of Manny suddenly becoming ineligible for some reason (I can't imagine why). Ryan Church doesn't currently have a team, but I figured with Manny out there in left, this squad would need as much outfield protection as they could get.