Developed Teams 2011: New York Mets

The other day, I happened upon a game on TV featuring the Mets... and what better reason to feature their developed lineup? And what more introduction do I need than that, seeing as you already must know the drill by now?

I'll say this for the Mets: they've been able to hold on to most of the top shelf talent they've developed. Which could be the sign of good management, who was able to lock up their best young homegrown players... or it could be an indication that they didn't develop a whole lot of top shelf talent that was worth trading away. YOU DECIDE!

A.J. Burnett - the developed pitcher with the best career - was a difficult one to place: he was drafted by the Mets and spent three years in the minors before being traded to Florida in the deal for Al Leiter. Although he only spent two years in the Marlins system, he pitched more innings for them before his debut (147.0 < 239.2) and pitched in higher levels (Rk, A- < A, AA). But there's something about someone getting traded as a prospect, even a low-level one, that seals the bond between that player and his original team. Also, just think of where this rotation would be without him!

Mike Pelfrey looks like he's on his way towards a sine wave career (alternating good and bad seasons) and Jonathan Niese still has a lot to prove with just one full season under his belt prior to 2011. Kazmir was once a top prospect, but he hasn't adjusted well to life on the west coast. Nelson Figueroa has been playing the journeyman for nine seasons, and just when he was slated to spend his first season in a major league rotation at age 37, he totally dropped the ball. Again, if we were going by 2011 stats, Dillon Gee would TOTALLY be in the rotation (he's certainly given my fantasy team a shot in the arm as a waiver claim) and Mejia would be... not on this list, as he hasn't appeared in a major league game, as of press time.

The biggest name to have left the Mets after being developed is the hottest closer (not) on the market, Heath Bell. In what has since turned out to be a lopsided trade, Bell was sent to the Padres in 2006, along with Royce Ring, in exchange for Jon Adkins and Ben Johnson. But who could've known that the former 69th round draft pick would have blossomed like he did? Bell's actually got a pretty solid bullpen complementing him out there: Lindstrom has closed before and represented his country in the World Baseball Classic as recently as 2009. Takahashi has flourished as both a swingman (in the NL) and a straight reliever (in the AL). And Dotel was just part of a major trade last month at the ripe age of 37. Aaron Heilman - once highly touted enough to have his name bandied about in a proposed trade for Barry Zito (along with his developed teammate Lastings Milledge, another flameout) - now is simply struggling in the bullpen.

The top four guys in this batting order, when healthy, can compete with the most stacked lineups in the league. However Reyes with his hamstrings, Davis with his ankle, and Wright with his back have all settled down for a long summer nap, courtesy of long stays on the DL for each of them. Wigginton was an All-Star last year, but that was largely because he played for a team that needed an All-Star. Carlos Gomez hasn't yet developed into the star we thought he would. And Daniel Murphy needed all of last year in the minors to figure out his life. With not much help off the bench (Jay Payton, in fact, is still technically a Free Agent), the club's stars will be under more and more pressure to stay healthy.

So there you have it: you have Met the Mets! I think my next venture, as we approach playoff season, will be looking at some teams that are actually in first place in their divisions and have legitimate shots at playing in October.

Developed Teams 2011: Cleveland Indians

Were you able to work out the identity of the other surprise Central Division contender who I mentioned in my last post? I didn't think it would be hard, but then again, I consider myself a sort of 'amateur expert' on this stuff. It should be no secret, however, that the other team I was referring to is the Cleveland Indians.

The pitching staff, which features CC Sabathia as headliner, looks a lot like the pitching staff to which CC belongs in real life - not a lot going on after the legitimate Ace. His fellow 1st round pick in the rotation, Jeremy Guthrie, now playing with Baltimore after being claimed on waivers, has some halfway decent peripherals to go with his 5-15 record, and Fausto Carmona has historically had two rotten seasons for every good one. His current rotation-mate in Cleveland, Josh Tomlin, is having a very good season, flashing some great control in just his second major league campaign.

UPDATE 8/8: When I posted this yesterday, I had listed J.D. Martin as the 5th starter, based solely on his pre-season rankings (seeing as he has spent 2011 as a swingman in AAA Syracuse), assuming that in real life, he'd compete with the two long-relief types I talk about below. However, later on, I realized a glaring omission in the statistics I had compiled for this project: namely the omission of Bartolo Colon. Maybe he slipped under my radar because he missed the entire 2010 season - but he shouldn't have because he was projected to start for the Yankees, and so far he's done a pretty nice job. The 5th starter spot is officially his, as noted in my revised graphic, above.

Jeanmar Gomez and David Huff both put up pretty good numbers for AAA Columbus, but have each made just a handful of starts for Cleveland this year.

Cleveland has developed a pretty deep bench of relievers, but they're notably lacking a proven 9th inning force. Mujica was good enough to be the centerpiece of a trade for a good young center fielder, so that gives you an idea of his talent, but he's logged only 2 Saves in his career. Pretty much the rest of the featured staff are young and effective setup men still with the Tribe (Lewis is in the minors and Laffey was traded just this off-season). And let's not forget Frank Herrmann, who has become a regular in 2011, and notable washed-up-but-once-solid veterans Danys Baez and David Riske.

The lineup's most notable features are two of the best sluggers from the '90s, Jim Thome and Manny Ramirez. Thome is currently a part-time DH, pursuing his 600th Home Run with the Twins, and Manny unceremoniously retired from the Rays after his second positive test for PED's. When healthy, Grady Sizemore has the ability to be a centerpiece for any lineup, either at the top or in the middle. Victor Martinez, while his skills behind the plate have been questioned, has leadership ability and intangibles galore. Just ask his current teammate on Detroit, Jhonny Peralta - the two All-Stars are doing their part to keep the Tigers in first place.

Peralta pushes Marco Scutaro off his normal position of SS, but he's had enough experience as a utility guy to be able to play anywhere in that infield. Before his struggles this year, I would have said that Kevin Kouzmanoff has the ability to provide great defense and middling power at the hot corner. And Russell Branyan can always be counted on to belt a few home runs, no matter the circumstances. Izturis is a great sparky presence off the bench and Ben Francisco is good enough to start in the outfield in the event of Manny suddenly becoming ineligible for some reason (I can't imagine why). Ryan Church doesn't currently have a team, but I figured with Manny out there in left, this squad would need as much outfield protection as they could get.

Developed Teams 2011: Pittsburgh Pirates

There are currently two total surprise teams who are in contention for the Central Division lead in their respective leads. These are both teams I like and want to see succeed. So in light of that, I have decided to profile them next in my developed teams project. The first of those teams is the Pittsburgh Pirates.

Rather than go by the developed players still with the club (of which there are a respectable seven, with one returning after a stint with other clubs), I'd like to go down the lineup as if I was introducing them before a game. I'll do a brief scouting report and go over some of their history. That might help keep this fresh. Oh, just for tradition's sake, there are a respectable seven developed players still with the team, one of which has returned after stints with other teams.

Leading off, we have Rajai Davis, who brings a lot of speed to the table and not much else - he leads the league in SB this year, but has only 1 HR and a negative defensiveWAR playing mostly Center Field. Luckily these Pirates have someone better to whom they can hand most of the AB's as the captain of the outfield: All-Star Andrew McCutchen. At age 24, the former 1st round pick has the potential to continue developing into a power-speed threat and a franchise player - plus he has really improved his fielding up the middle. Between those two is another first rounder, Neil Walker, who burst onto the scene last year and has put up some respective, if not eye-popping, numbers.

We all know how Jose Bautista has found one of the most impressive power strokes in the game last year in Toronto. What we also (mostly) know is that h started his career as a utility infielder in the Pirates' system, even though he bounced around a couple of other major league teams as a Rule 5 pick before putting on a Pittsburgh uniform. Looking at his minor league career, it's clear which team did the developing. You'll notice that Aramis Ramirez is at 1B on this team, which is strange because he's never played even an inning at first base in his major or minor league career. Well, we couldn't have both him and former first-round pick Pedro Alvarez both manning the hot corner (and the best developed first baseman on the squad, Steve Pearce, has only had a couple of cups of coffee so far in the majors), so someone had to shift. Since neither of them play particularly well in the field, I figured it was a wash as to who made the move.

Jeff Keppinger appeared in a non-developed related lineup I posted about just the other day, and although he hasn't played a lot of SS the last couple of years, that's where he's listed on MLB 11: The Show, so it all works out. Ryan Doumit gets the nod due to his 2010, and Jason Kendall gets the back-up job because of what he's meant to the team over the course of his (mostly early) career, although if we were going by more recent performance it might have made more sense to include Ronny Paulino. Also Nyjer Morgan is in that top bench spot - signifying the guy who would most likely DH in an interleague situation. Based on last year's/his career numbers, I would have liked to include Jose Guillen in a more substantial role, but seeing as he remained unsigned this year and is ostensibly retired, it just didn't seem right.

The starting staff is a little enigmatic, filled with mid-level talents and questionable players in general. Bronson Arroyo had put up decent numbers, although nobody quite knew how, given his stuff, but the truth might be just about catching up to him at age 34. Tom Gorzelanny, although he was picked in the 2nd round, has never really projected as anything more than a number 3 or 4 starter. Paul Maholm has shown flashes of competence, but the 1st rounder hasn't racked up enough strikeouts to be really effective. Zach Duke has been given a new lease on life by the Diamondbacks, but he's in the process of squandering that away. And Chris Young has been good, but he hasn't avoided injury since, well, ever.

The bullpen is a different story, with two top-shelf closing talents available in Leo Nunez and Matt Capps. The bullpen is stacked with lefties, with Burnett and Gonzalez (who are both struggling a bit this year), and Joe Beimel (who is not only a hometown hero, but the subject of a very catchy bullpen-related tune during his time co-setting up for Takashi Saito with Jonathan Broxton on the Dodgers). Their long reliever, veteran and all-around good guy Tim Wakefield, has alternated between starter and swingman for most of his career, and it looks like he'll settle in with the latter for his twilight years.

So there you have it. If you can guess which team I'm choosing next time (it's not hard), drop me a line in the comments section. I like reading comments...

Trade Deadline Analysis

It's not that I don't like my Developed Teams Project... it's just that newsworthy events keep happening in and around the Baseball world, and I'm drawn to write about those rather than stick to an arbitrary deadline I've set for myself for finishing all 30 teams before the playoffs. Such as the much more exciting, very real, non-waiver trade deadline that just passed this Sunday. Lots of people changed teams that day. Not as many as some people thought. But still it's been pretty exciting following all the action. Here's a 25-man roster (cuz I like those) made up of all the players who moved this deadline:

So, yeah, that's what it would look like if I were in charge. Rather than go through the above image, I'd like to go through position by position, using the numbered guide (which is how you mark the positions while you're keeping score, if you're curious).

1 Starting Pitcher
MLB: 5
Prospects: 14

Believe it or not, those five above were the only Major League caliber starters who changed hands on/before this deadline. Fister has surprisingly been the most successful, but this wouldn't be the first unexpectedly dominant starter Detroit has picked up from Seattle in recent years. (I'm looking at you, Jarrod Washburn, 2009... and we all remember how well that turned out, right?) The most celebrated pitcher on this list (Jimenez) has put up the least impressive numbers, having fallen from his incredibly fluky 2010. But we should have all seen that coming. I mean, who goes 15-1 before the All-Star Break? WHO DOES THAT?!!? Hopefully he picks things up and keeps the dark horse Indians in contention.

Bedard came back from a nonexistent 2010 to draw attention from a first-place team. It's fortunate that Boston made that deal, since it looks like Clay Buchholz is going to be out for the rest of the season. Edwin Jackson should be getting used to the late-July move routine, after a 2010 deadline deal sent him to Chicago from the Diamondbacks. Speaking of the Diamondbacks, if they are able to hold off the defending champion Giants and make it to the playoffs, Jason Marquis will have been to the post-season at least once with every team he has played for except the Nationals. I mean, that's the case already, but still...

For those of you not familiar with minorleagueball.com, John Sickels ranks each club's top 20 prospects for each year. Of those 14 predominantly minor-league starters who were traded during the 2011 deadline frenzy, 11 of them were ranked by Sickels. Four have B+ ratings: Drew Pomeranz and Alex White, who went from CLE to COL in the Jimenez deal; Zach Stewart, acquired by CHW in the 3-way deal that sent Edwin Jackson to STL; and Robbie Erlin, who helped TEX acquire Mike Adams from SD.

Three more have B ratings: Zack Wheeler, traded straight-up by SF to NYM for Carlos Beltran; Jarred Cosart, who moved from PHI to HOU in the Hunter Pence trade; and Joseph Gardner, another piece of the Jimenez extravaganza. (Looks to me like Colorado got quite a return on their investment. Whether or not these three pieces will be ready to complement Tulo and CarGo before their long-term deals expire remains to be seen.)

C and C+ are average, so no need to mention them here. I will mention Charlie Furbush, 1) because he's got a cool name, and 2) because he has spent some time pitching in the majors for DET before getting sent to SEA for Fister.

1.1 Closer
MLB: 1
Prospects: 2

Just Francisco Rodriguez as the sole Closer of note here, and as this deal happened well before the deadline, I'll assume you've already heard all about it. A couple of guys who have racked up a few saves in the minors, but nobody ranked by Sickels, so we'll leave it be.

1.2 Reliever
MLB: 10
Prospects: 8

Wide open market for relievers this year. Adams and Uehara will help TEX in their push to repeat as AL champions. David Pauley has been a surprising success, and Brad Ziegler's crazy delivery has continued to work for him. TOR gave up two of its big pieces (Frasor and Rzepczynski, which I've learned is pronounced zep-CHIN-ski, according to ESPN) in the same 3-way deal, but got a very promising major league ready player in return, so I endorse that decision heartily. Octavio Dotel also left in that same trade, but he barely missed the cut.

Zep and veteran Trever Miller were the only two lefties moved, while Brian Fuentes and Craig Breslow stayed put in OAK. Tommy Hunter was also traded in the Uehara deal, despite pitching in the playoffs for TEX last year. He spent some time starting in the minors this year, but only appeared in relief in the majors. I wonder if he'll ever get back on track to be a viable starter. It could only help the Orioles.

2 Catcher
MLB: 0
Prospects: 2

Neither of the two catchers (Tim Federowicz nor Julio Rodriguez) were ranked by Sickels in 2011, although Fed did get a mention in Boston's "Others of Note" section. Seems like a very lackluster centerpiece for the Dodgers to get back for Trayvon Robinson, their organization's #3 ranked prospect, who went to SEA to help BOS get Bedard. Maybe it was a future salary dump by Ned Colletti, in preparation for the McCourt divorce proceedings to affect the team for years down the line...

3 First Base
MLB: 1
Prospects: 5

Derrek Lee has been disappointing for BAL, but we'll see if going back to the NL Central and joining a surprising contender (PIT) will pump him up a little bit. Two of the "prospects" listed here (Chris Davis and Brandon Allen) have spent disappointing time in the majors, but are currently tearing up AAA. Not much for them to prove in the minors; now they just have to man up and perform - for BAL and OAK respectively. The only ranked prospect is Jonathan Singleton, who draws a B+ and status as Philadelphia's #2 prospect. Hopefully he'll go some of the way to making Houston a respectable franchise at some point down the line (he's currently in A+ level).

4 Second Base
MLB: 2
Prospects: 0

Orlando Cabrera played 2B for CLE, but will likely move over to SS for SF, since the other guy on this list (Jeff Keppinger) will likely step in the second-sack position. What makes Cabrera better than Tejada is anybody's guess, but thankfully for the Giants, neither of these two were the top acquisition by their team this year.

5 Third Base
MLB: 4
Prospects: 1

The Royals traded both Wilson Betemit and Mike Aviles this year, which was to be expected with one of the best 3B prospects in the game (Mike Moustakas) hot on both of their heels. (Never mind that he's currently hitting under .200...) Jerry Hairston is listed at 3B, but he's also played a fair amount of LF this year, and hopes to help MIL with his diversity. Mark Teahen was basically a throw-in for TOR in the Jackson-Rasmus deal. And the lone prospect, Francisco Martinez (C+ by Sickels), goes from DET to SEA in the ever-present Fister deal.


6 Shortstop
MLB: 1
Prospects: 2

Yup, Rafael Furcal is it, he of the .197 AVG in his injury-plagued first half with the Dodgers. Yamaico Navarro (C+), late of the Red Sox, can play every infield position and might give Yuniesky Betancourt a run for his money in KC sooner rather than later.  Zach Walters (of Note) was tearing up A ball when he was traded as part of the Marquis deal, but might have to settle for a utility role with WAS if he comes up soon, as they seem pretty set at all three infield positions.

7 Left Field
MLB: 3
Prospects: 2

A couple of starters at this position were moved at the deadline - one who was projected to start for the Reds (Gomes) and one who emerged as a surprise contender for the Blue Jays (Patterson). Incidentally, the guy Patterson replaced in the projected lineup (Rivera) was also moved, and he's currently picking up some starts at first base for the Dodgers. Speaking of the Dodgers, they sent their organization's #3 prospect (Trayvon Robinson, B) to the Mariners in the Erik Bedard deal, and didn't get nought back but a handful of unranked prospects from the Red Sox. To round out the list, I feel like I should mention Thomas Neal (B+, SF's #5 ranked prospect) who went to Cleveland for Orlando Cabrera.

8 Center Field
MLB: 3
Prospects: 1

Perhaps no team did as good a job filling a glaring void as the Braves did when they acquired speedy leadoff center fielder Michael Bourn. The Blue Jays will enjoy Colby Rasmus, as he's a tremendous young talent, but they have plenty of offense. As for the other two not mentioned above, Jordan Schafer played in the majors for Atlanta, but he won't make a difference on baseball's worst squad, in this year or the next. And Erik Komatsu, (C+, MIL's 10th ranked prospect) was exchanged for superutility player Jerry Hairston.

9 Right Field
MLB: 5
Prospects: 4

Right Field is where most of the magic happened this deadline. Hunter Pence is one of the most promising young players in the game and Carlos Beltran is a proven veteran who has just this season found a burst of new life. We know how Beltran reacts to the late-season rental dynamic - he went to the NLCS with the Astros after being acquired in a pre-deadline deal in 2004 - but we'll see if Pence brings his game to the next level (i.e. superstardom) while playing for a contender. Ryan Ludwick, on the bench above, will hopefully give the Pirates the additional offensive shot in the arm they need to keep fighting for their division.

The other two major league quality RF'ers are Kosuke Fukudome (who hopes to play Ludwick's role for the Indians) and Casper Wells (a ready-to-play prospect shipped from DET to SEA for Doug Fister). Neither of the minor leaguers at this position were ranked, but three of the four (Chih-Hsien Chiang, Alex Castellanos, and Bill Rhinehart) are tearing it up stats-wise in AA-ball.

Developed Teams 2011: Arizona Diamondbacks

My grand plan was to profile the Diamondbacks in honor of their fair city playing host to the 2011 All-Star Game. But that was over two weeks ago and we're now closer to the Trade Deadline than the mid-summer classic. However, it's better late than never, and The Plan will continue as promised... if a little behind schedule.

For such a young team - having existed for just 13 short seasons - they have a remarkable store of talent. Their offensive prowess is evident from the list above, even if the key middle-of-the-order bats didn't spend considerable time actually playing for the Diamondbacks. Dan Uggla was picked up by the Marlins Rule 5 style before his debut, and put up very impressive power numbers for the Fish. Carlos Gonzalez was a major piece of a blockbuster trade to the A's while still in the minors (the same trade in which the D-Backs parted with Brett Anderson, btw). Carlos Quentin played about a full season's worth of games over his first two seasons in Arizona before having his best years in the south side of Chicago.

Of the recently-developed Diamondbacks still with the team, the breakout performances of Justin Upton and Miguel Montero have more than overshadowed Stephen Drew's disappointing production. Mark Reynolds just left the team last year, and we know he can mash, but he also can strike out a Major League record amount of times. The guys on the bench are nothing spectacular - Cust and Barajas are the only two who have spent any significant time starting for a Major League team. The rest are solid backups, which is more than some teams I've looked at for this project can say.

What really amazes me about the D-Backs is the abundance of pitching that has come out of their system over the years. Not all of it is top-shelf talent, but using just the players included on MLB 11: The Show's rosters, the 'Backs have 29 pitchers to their name. It's interesting that the game's youngest team (tied) has developed twice as many pitchers as the game's oldest team (bonus points if you can name that team. Hint: they already have an entry in this project).

As I said, not all of them are that high-caliber. Their three highest-ranked pitchers (according to MLB.com's preseason rankings) fall between 100 and 120: one is a potential star who's shown flashes of brilliance but can't escape injury (Brett Anderson), another has the exact same description, just replace "injury" with "mediocrity" (Max Scherzer), and the third is currently playing out the veteran star closer fantasy (Jose Valverde).

Brad Penny has had a nice career for himself (he's another guy who started his Major League career with Florida after lingering in the Arizona farm system), and Chris Capuano has been living comeback to comeback. It was of course an act of purest optimism to have put Brandon Webb on that list at all, seeing as he hasn't pitched since 2009. But the Sports Illustrated baseball preview had his name there, and MLB has him as the next-highest ranked pitcher after the above three I already mentioned, so I figured, whatever.

After Valverde, their bullpen gets a little weak, but thankfully they have enough surplus starters to back them up, even if everyone not mentioned above has struggled mightily this year. But, as I've mentioned many times before, this team was put together with pre-season rankings, since that's when I started compiling these lists, believe it or not. And since it's taken me so long to get through THIS much of the project, imagine how much more complicated it would have been while trying to keep up to date with all the stats...

Watching Games on "Double-Bloop"

Throughout most of this season, I've been somewhat neglectful of the actual standings, stats, and on-the-field proceedings, preferring to focus on historical data in the form of my various fanciful projects. But every once in a while, the stars of the baseball world align and draw you to the television for an especially memorable event. The Home Run Derby/All-Star Game was one such event. This weekend's four-games-in-three-days series between the Oakland A's and the Anaheim Angels was another.

I love watching the games live whenever I can, but more often than not my schedule requires me to record the games and revisit them later via DVR. When watching the games on delay, I find it increasingly difficult to limit my use of fast-forward to the commercials, and sit through the entire telecast. If a pitcher is taking his sweet time "setting the tempo" or a batter steps out of the box to adjust his unmentionables, or there's a break in the action to collect shards of broken glass from the field, I find myself double-blooping forward.*

Quadruple-Bloop (Double-Double-Bloop)

* "Double-Bloop" is a term I first heard from my cousin referring to watching a previously recorded program on the DVR at an increased speed. It was based on the sound made by TiVo systems when you push the fast-forward button two times in quick succession. As it happens, I don't have TiVo, but I still use the term... in the same way as I don't always use the Kleenex or Band-Aid brands, yet I'll still ask for them. 10 points for Branded America.

However, due to the uncertain nature of DVR technology, I'll often find myself wanting to skip just a few minutes of treacle here and there, but end up blasting way too far into the future or intermittently stopping and starting so much that it basically doesn't save any time and only adds to the frustration. So while speeding through Sunday afternoon's game last night, I developed a system of watching games on double-bloop that provides a good overview/summary while still letting you get through the game in less time than it takes to watch Return of the King.

First of all, I will watch the first three innings uninterrupted. This gives me a chance to see every hitter in the lineup bat at least once, get a sense of how each pitcher is throwing, and evaluate how the two teams look on the field. I've noted many times that Baseball is broken up into thirds, and in my experience, the first third of a game is usually the most telling about how the general tone of the game will play out. For example, when the A's tagged the Angels for 8 runs in the first inning last night, you could be pretty.... pretty..... pretty sure how the rest of the game would turn out.

Then, when the away team's pitcher walks off the mound after the third inning, and the increased speed begins, I immediately fix my eyes on the game status graphic in the corner/along the top of the screen. A lot of times, the action happening on the field is too fast to follow without getting dizzy, so I use the graphic as a visual cue to point out things it might be worth watching. This is also a strategy I picked up from my cousin, but for some reason, the system just clicked last night.

The first thing I look at is the score. If any number of the score changes, I immediately hit play and even skip back one or two 30-second intervals (if your system doesn't do that automatically on double-bloop). Scoring plays aren't always the most exciting or highlight-worthy, but runs are explicitly what win games and what most tangibly shift the momentum in a game. Even if it's not an especially interesting play, I still like to have a good handle on who scored, who drove him in, against whom, and generally who was involved in the play.

The next thing I look at is the number of outs. If at any time the number of outs jumps to two (as it will at least 17 times every game), I will push play and watch until the final out of the inning. Again, two-out plays aren't necessarily any more exciting than one- or no-out plays, but as far as getting a feel for the overall progress of the game, it's especially nice to see how a pitcher finishes off the opposition and also to see the between-innings line score. If we jump right from a one-on, one-out situation to a commercial, that indicates a double-play, so I will usually stop and skip back to see it, because double plays are generally either exciting or well-executed fundamentally - or both.

There are exceptions and situations not covered by these rudimentary rules. For instance, what about pitching changes? Spectacular diving catches? Benches-clearing brawls? The system isn't perfect - in fact, it hasn't been beta tested beyond the course of one game. But this is how I have decided to do it, and will continue to until I discover something better. And I've deemed it exciting enough to put out here on the Internets for all to see. Prove me right, people! Prove me right...

The All-Star Game!

Remember when the All-Star game happened two days ago?  Well, I wrote something about it yesterday!  Here's a link to Charge-Shot!!!, a blog that holds a very special place in my heart... specifically a place that occurs on Wednesday afternoons...

All-Star Tuesday: One Year Later

Liveblogging the 2011 State Farm Home Run Derby!

11:08pm EST


And will you look at that!?  Cano has come back, not only to tie Gonzalez, but to beat him with two outs to spare!  Just when I was beginning to lose interest.  Just when I thought it was not about the competition.  Just when I thought the rest of the broadcast would be comprised of the first-timer going through the motions and flaming out after an impressive two rounds, he comes back with a flair for the dramatic and wins it all, proving that the Derby can be exciting and unbelievable and fun for the whole family.

We've had a lot of fun here tonight, but what we should take away from all this is that it's never too late for a feat of sheer will to help you overcome nearly insurmountable odds.  And that you should never give up, no matter how stacked the circumstances are against you.  And that it's not over until it's over.

I hope you've all had fun reading my real-time thoughts about the amazing piece of history we just saw occur.  And since I've still got an hour before my flight starts boarding, I've got nothing left to do but recount it in my head over and over....




10:51pm EST


Fielder's long road to 15 he needs to keep his league alive in this competition is off to a slow start.  I think we can call this one right now for the American League, both in terms of cumulative totals (53-19) and in that the eventual winner will come from the AL.  The NL may have won its first All-Star game in a long time last year, but they will have to wait until next year to seek triumph in the Derby.

So it comes down to this, a battle between AL contestants, between AL East players, between representatives from perhaps the most storied rivalry in the sport right now, the Yankees and the Red Sox.  Each has exactly the same home run total coming in (not that it matters).  Each has exactly the same on the line.

It's looking a little one-sided now, as Gonzalez continues his hot streak and gives Cano an equally astronomical mark to reach as he puts up a 13-spot on the board in the finals.  Pretty straightforward now as Cano is finished unless he can perform exactly as he did in the second round.  No flameouts allowed, or the Yankee's night is finished!




10:28pm EST


It's always around this time in the Home Run Derby that my interest starts to fade.  I've seen all the contestants take their swings.  This cumulative second round is really just an extension of the first round, which we've already seen happen.  The competition aspect is a little muted, unless Prince Fielder can follow up his awesome swing-off performance (5 HRs in 5 swings!) with an even more impressive second round - the lone NL representative will need another 5 just to put him ahead of the leader's first round performance, and that's assuming Gonzalez goes homerless in his next 10 outs.

Meanwhile Ortiz added 4 to his total, pulling him even with Gonzalez, so that all his teammate needs to surpass the team captain is one more.  Cano continues to mash, all but assuring him a spot in the final two.  (Although he'd better pull back if he wants to have anything left in the tank for the non-cumulative final round.)  Thus unless Fielder goes on a spree of 10+ homers in a row, he's pretty much out for the count.  Is it me, or does making the first and second rounds cumulative put way too much emphasis on the first round?  I guess the competition part is less important than just seeing all those power hitters up there doing their things.

Wow, Cano just blasted his 11th in the second round, to go with his 8 in the first round.  I predict a flameout, just like what happened to Jason Giambi in the fated 2001 contest when he lost to Luis Gonzalez after setting a first-round record.  To return to the present, Adrian Gonzalez just eliminated his teammate and captain with a single home run, but keeps on blasting more and more, tying Cano with 20 total homers.  (At least now each contestant has an equal chance of flameout.)  Fielder, the NL team captain now needs to belt at least 15 bombs in this second round to remain in contention.  At least he's going last to maintain the drama.  Although it's looking more and more like the blowout we knew it would be in the first round....




9:47pm EST


The two batters last to hit are the "Team Captains" of the AL and NL squads.  I'm watching this from an airport bar, sitting too far away to read any of the closed captions of the commentary, so I'm not exactly sure how this works.  In the rules, it says the top home run totals advance to the next rounds, so what should it matter what team they're on or who their captain is?  But I guess leadership counts for something, as David Ortiz and Prince Fielder get last ups.

I remember when "Big Papi" went through a scare a couple of years ago, where commentators and fans pronounced him gone from the ranks of serious home run threats.  But although he'll likely never again approach the 50-homer totals he's amassed in seasons past, he's still showing some pop out here in the desert.

Prince Fielder is an appropriate contestant to be up right now, especially considering all the hype surrounding the new Moneyball movie coming out.  (No, I haven't seen the trailers, and no, I don't plan to, despite my fascination with both the Oakland A's and the entertainment industry; Spoiler Free is the Way to Be.)  Some of you might recall that back in 2002, the A's draft team was terrified that the Brewers, who picked before the A's, would deprive them of their prize, outfielder Nick Swisher.  How happy they were when supposedly sentimental reasons (Fielder's father, Cecil, played for the Brewers in the past) led to Prince's selection, leaving Swisher for the A's.  And it's a good thing Beane didn't pick Fielder when he had the chance - when your team is second-to-last in the league with a .337 Slugging Percentage, who needs an offensive force with 50-homer potential?

Well, it's settled!  Or is it?  A-Gon and Robbie Cano are definitely advancing, but then we have three guys tied with five home runs apiece all vying for the last two spots.  It looks like we're going into a 5-swing tie-breaking swing-off for each three.  Since the totals from the first two rounds are cumulative, these tie-breaker round homers don't count towards that total.  It's nice that there's still a chance for equal participation from AL and NL... although the advantage clearly goes to the two AL-guys with high totals.

The final tally (swing-off totals in parenthesis, advancing players highlighted):

AL: 26

Gonzalez: 9

Cano: 8

Bautista: 4

Ortiz: 5 (+4)

NL: 15

Holliday: 5 (+2)

Weeks: 3

Kemp: 2

Fielder: 5 (+5!)

9:19pm EST


Jose Bautista: where did this guy come from, am I right?  Someone without any real history of smacking a lot of home runs last year suddenly discovers some amazing power and leads the league getting a chance to start in Toronto.  Now he's on pace to do something that has been done only eight (8) times in Major League history: finish the year with more than 60 home runs.  He's not going to set any Derby records with just four homers, but I'd rather have someone who can hit them in games than hit them in exhibitions any day.

I've got to say, I'm not too excited by Matt Kemp's chances to put up a lot of dingers here in Arizona.  He is famous for smacking hitting his homers to straightaway center field, and this park has a gigantic wall up there, plus it is extra deep.  I hope he doesn't try to change his approach to pull or push too much, because it's that straight-out power that helps him succeed in the 395-foot-to-CF Dodger Stadium. And sure enough, he didn't get one out of there until his final outs, with most of his hardest hits landing for flyouts to straightaway center.  I've got to say, I'm not very optimistic about the National League's chances so far...

AL: 21
Gonzalez: 9
Cano: 8
Bautista: 4

NL: 10
Holliday: 5
Weeks: 3
Kemp: 2






8:59pm EST


Wow, Cano's off to a hot start.  Three bombs in his first four swings.  If only he hit enough dingers during the season to crack the top ten in homers in the AL, it might justify his presence a little more?  Maybe it has something to do with his position - he and Rickie Weeks are both second basemen, not a position historically noted for home run power.  And yet there's his teammate, Curtis Granderson (second in the league in HR) providing Cano with a rosin bag and pumping up the crowd rather than taking cuts at the plate.  Puzzling...

Cano does have some kind of sweet swing, though, doesn't he?  Which brings me to another concern that potential #HRDerby contestants seemingly should have: the effect that taking so many "fake" swings has on one's regular-season swing.  Maybe it's some weird confirmation bias, but it seems to me that in the past, players who have performed well in the Home Run Derby suddenly experience a drop in power production immediately following the exhibition.  Perhaps Rickie Weeks is aware of that possibility and is using his bright-blue neon shoes as a superstitious way to combat this real or imagined trend.

I don't know if anyone has conducted any kind of study on this, but Weeks seems to be most likely to suffer a post-derby power outage than the rest of these contestants.  He only last year developed his power stroke, and who knows how all this emphasis on his big flies will affect his approach at the plate in the future.  Perhaps his poor showing in this year's Derby (only 3 home runs) will cause him to second-guess his swing and start making adjustments.  I wish him continued success - if only for the sake of his younger brother, who has just taken the first steps on what promises to be a long and fruitful career with the Oakland A's - but don't care too much about the rest of 2011, seeing as he's not on my fantasy team.

AL: 17
Gonzalez: 9
Cano: 8

NL: 8
Holliday: 5
Weeks: 3



8:41pm, EST

Looking at the list of players appearing in the 2011 State Farm Home Run Derby in Phoenix tonight, I can't help but cock my head to the side in slight confusion at how they select the participants.  I get that there are four representatives from the AL and four from the NL, but shouldn't it be the top Home Run hitters from each league?  You'd think so, but then why is Adrian Gonzalez (tied for 10th in the AL) stepping in to lead off for this squad?

And I know Matt Holliday did a good job of picking up his team when Phat Albert was down with that wrist injury, but when his another one of his teammates (Lance Berkman) is surprisingly leading the National League in Home Runs, don't you think he deserves to be up there swinging the bat, rather than commenting from the sidelines?  As much fun as it is to see the hulking, bald-headed, cornfed Sooner swing the bat, dude's not even in the top ten in the league.

I have to plead ignorance here; do the powers that be on the Home Run Derby committee go down the line of the players with the highest HR totals in each league until they get four that say yes?  Or is there some algorithm they make use of to determine the best contestants - one that takes into account home run totals from the current year, the previous year, while also weighing in some special "showmanship quotient" to make sure the broadcast is entertaining?

Maybe Berkman was approached for this honor and declined.  His amazing first-half comeback makes for a great story, but maybe he doesn't want to jinx it by putting himself in this kind of spotlight.  Maybe at age 35 and with a troubling injury history he's worried he might tweak something over the course of several dozen exhibition swings.  Or maybe he wasn't even asked, for some undisclosed reason.  Even after thinking about all these questions during the first commercial break, I haven't been able to figure it out.  Respond with thoughts in the comments section, or Tweet them at me why not at @Hunter_S_Batman

AL - Adrian Gonzalez: 9

NL - Matt Holliday: 5

Developed Teams 2011: Philadelphia Phillies

Last week, in addition to meeting a White Sox fan from Chicago, I also met a Phillies fan from Philadelphia (imagine that).  I know several Phillies phans, but this is the first I've met since starting this Developed Teams project for my blog, so it brought to mind what might happen if we put a roster together with only the players that the Phillies developed and shepherded (most if not all of the way) to the majors.  Here it is:

When I did this project in the past, it was almost as difficult finding enough position players for the Phillies as it was to find starting pitchers for the Reds.  There were almost no hitters to spare, but luckily I could scrounge up just enough to fill a lineup card.  The majority of the heavy hitters are recently developed and hence still with the team (although Rollins, Utley, and Howard are all three reaching maturity and have all three had their issues with injuries).  Domonic Brown is in there over Pat Burrell cuz he was just ranked so darn high before his pre-season wrist injury, and it seemed wrong not to have such a sure future star in this lineup, even despite his lack of experience.  And Carlos Ruiz is becoming one of the most solid catchers in the National League.

As far as players the Phillies have let go, speed demon Michael Bourn is probably the best right now - he's tearing it up on the basepaths currently leading the league in steals.  Scott Rolen and Marlon Byrd are both well past their primes, but can also both contribute with their bats.  Pat Burrell is a former franchise-type player who's recently been relegated to spot-starter duty.  Nick Punto is still a solid backup utility infielder and "Tofu" Lou Marson is a fan favorite in Cleveland.

Starting pitching is this club's biggest strength by far - the Phillies are one of the few clubs who have managed to develop more quality starters than relievers.  Looking at just 2011, you'll see more struggling pitchers (Myers, Floyd, Drabek, Happ) than successful ones (Hamels, Wolf, Carrasco)... and even one who hasn't pitched yet in '011, and likely won't (Silva).  But as far as track record goes (or in Drabek's case, enormous potential), they definitely have all proven to be effective starters at some point in their major league careers.  Ryan Madson is the only pitcher who's had a taste of closing (at least they had one!), and Kyle Kendrick has proven himself an effective swingman.

If we were going by 2011 alone - which it is now more conceivable to do, since we've got half a season under our belts... although I will refrain from that and stick to my guns about using mostly pre-season predictions - Josh Outman would have replaced Silva on the list of long relievers, due to his (so far) successful comeback from a lost 2010 season.  Also in the bullpen, Simon would be out (citing lack of production more than his recent troubles with the law) and Tejeda has barely played this year.  Taking their places would be surprising success story Antonio Bastardo (0.84 ERA, 5 saves, in 32 innings) and Taylor Buchholz, a bargain-bin pickup by the Mets who is actually contributing at the major league level.

Strengths:
- Starting pitching across the board.  Veterans, prospects, mid-level starters, you name it.  Plenty of quality innings from this staff.
- A powerful middle of the lineup, provided it can stay healthy.  And good tablesetters at the top, with plenty of speed.
- A pretty versatile and talented bench to boot, with all positions adequately covered.

Weaknesses:
- Although it doesn't show up in this 25-man roster, a complete lack of depth.  Philly developed only 15 hitters total, which leaves just two (2) to stock in the "minors" in case of injury.


Next time, in honor of Tuesday's All-Star Game in Phoenix, I'll be profiling the Developed Arizona Diamondbacks.

Developed Teams 2011: Chicago White Sox

Last week, I met someone from Chicago.  "Are you a Cubs fan?" I asked, expecting her to shower her support on the lovable losers.  "Nope," she replied, "White Sox... even though I'm from the North Side."  Now, although I have somewhat of a professional relationship with the Cubs, I've always admired the White Sox, mostly due to Frank Thomas and memories of one of my friends from 3rd grade who wore his Sox cap until it turned into a Sox yarmulke.  So here's a team made up of all the best players developed by the Chicago White Sox:

Not a lot of developed Sox are still with the team: only 7 by my count - and the two batters on the bench are only there because of a lack of an established backup catcher or utility infielder.  The only two batters in the lineup have had subpar seasons from the left side of the infield.  And the only pitcher in the rotation is actually having a decent season despite a typically lackluster strikeout/walk ratio.  The bullpen has a couple of strong arms: one projected closer who's been bumped to middle relief, and vice versa.

The high turnover rate makes this developed team one of the most exciting, because it includes a lot of people we are not used to seeing in Sox uniforms.  Some of them - most notably Chris Young, Gio Gonzalez, and Mike Morse - never suited up for the Sox in the majors.  Others - such as Magglio Ordonez, Carlos Lee, and Jon Garland - were Sox mainstays who played some of the best years of their careers in pinstripes.

You'll notice a glut of outfielders, of varying age and skill.  I picked Cameron to start, partly because he had the most secure projected starting job out of Spring Training and partly because he's had the longest and best career out of the other two backups.  His actual 2011 hasn't been up to snuff, but the same can be said for the other options.

Also remember that Mike Morse started the season as an outfielder and is only at first base for the Nationals due to an injury to Adam LaRoche... but before you accuse me of switching stuff around midseason after I explicitly said I was basing these lists mostly on preseason predictions, let me say that I already had Morse listed as a first baseman because that's his position on MLB 11 The Show.  I made the conscious choice to put him at first over Brandon Allen (despite the current Arizona Diamondback's higher rating in the MLB.com predictions) due to his slightly higher production in '10.  And unlike Cameron, that choice is paying off.

The pitching staff has a couple of promising breakout hits: Daniel Hudson, who absolutely KILLED IT after his trade to Arizona last year, and Gio(vanny) Gonzalez, who's currently anchoring my fantasy rotation.  Mark Buehrle and Jon Garland provide "veteran leadership."  And such nondescript starters as Clayton Richard and Brandon McCarthy are making names for themselves in other rotations.

Recap:

Strengths:
- Good mix of young and veteran hitters would produce strong numbers if they ever got a chance to all play together.
- Lots of budding stars anchored by cool veterans in the rotation (plus they've got starters to spare).
- Established relievers join some young prospects in the bullpen.

Weaknesses:
- Lack of infield versatility off the bench, putting a lot of pressure on starters to stay healthy.
- No one pitcher who has served as a successful closer for multiple seasons.


Next time: Philadelphia Phillies